Amazon.com: There was a moment when the
United States had the Vietnam War wrapped up, writes military
historian Lewis Sorley (biographer of two Vietnam-era U.S. Army
generals, Creighton Abrams and Harold Johnson). "The fighting
wasn't over, but the war was won," he says in this convention-shaking
book. "This achievement can probably best be dated in late
1970." South Vietnam was ready to carry on the battle without
American ground troops and only logistical and financial support.
Sorley says that replacing General Westmoreland with Abrams in
1968 was the key. "The tactics changed within fifteen minutes
of Abrams's taking command," remarked one officer. Abrams
switched the war aims from destruction to control; he was less
interested in counting enemy body bags than in securing South
Vietnam's villages.
A Better War is unique among histories
of the Vietnam War in that it focuses on the second half of the
conflict, roughly from Abrams's arrival to the fall of Saigon
in 1975. Other volumes, such as Stanley Karnow's Vietnam and
Neil Sheehan's A Bright Shining Lie, tend to give short shrift
to this period. Sorley shows how the often-overlooked Abrams
strategy nearly succeeded--indeed, Sorley says it did succeed,
at least until political leadership in the United States let
victory slip away. Sorley cites other problems, too, such as
low morale among troops in the field, plus the harmful effects
of drug abuse, racial disharmony, and poor discipline. In the
end, the mighty willpower of Abrams and diplomatic allies Ellsworth
Bunker and William Colby was not enough. But, with its strong
case that they came pretty close to winning, A Better War is
sure to spark controversy. --John J. Miller
A remarkable memoir of small unit leadership
and the coming of age of a young soldier in combat in Vietnam.
Truly a classic of military history. Colonel McDonough graduated
from the US Military Academy at West Point and served as an infantry
platoon leader in the legendary 173d Airborne Brigade.
"Stolen Valor" reviewed in The
Weekly Standard:"Hard-nosed, provocative, and courageous,
'Stolen Valor' masterfully and on occasion gleefully debunks
some of the popular canards and much of the anecdotal record
about Vietnam veterans...For me, a reporter who is also a Vietnam
veteran, 'Stolen Valor' goes on the shelf somewhere near Neil
Sheehan's 'A Bright Shining Lie,' David Halberstam's 'The Best
and the Brightest,' and a few other books whose lasting value
is that they make more comprehensible some of the epic complexities
of Vietnam, which was the central cultural event of my generation."
-- Joe Sharkey, in The Weekly Standard, Sept. 7, 1998
Search
our Site!
Questions and comments concerning
this site should be directed to the Webmaster